Forum archive
turnkey-otrs-12.0-squeeze-x86 - Hilariously, outrageously out of date.
The OTRS developers are kind enough to have an update scoreboard available when you first log into OTRS to see what patching needs to be done. This image was supposedly updated August 21, 2012...
| OTRS 3.1.12 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.11 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.17 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 2.4.15 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.10 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.16 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.9 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.8 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.14 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.7 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.6 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.5 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.4 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.3 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.12 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.2 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.1.1 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Major) |
| OTRS 3.0.11 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.10 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Security) |
| OTRS 3.0.9 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.8 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.7 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Security) |
| OTRS 3.0.6 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.5 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.4 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.3 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.2 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 3.0.1 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Major) |
| OTRS 2.4.12 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Patch) |
| OTRS 2.4.10 is available! Please update now. (Release Note - Level: Security) |
For some reason I'm not buying it, and sure not using it. In fact, I've gone and deleted the other handful of disk images I grabbed, because holy crap... Sure, maybe apt-get update was run, but this thing's 21 months out of date and counting for the actual software package featured.
I appreciate the effort that goes into these images (otherwise I'd not be trying to avoid doing it myself), but this one's a bit much, isn't it?
You seem to lack understanding of how Debian works. Debain is built for stability, not to have the 'latest and greatest version'. Due to extensive (and I mean extensive) testing (which takes months and months, sometimes years) by the time Debain stable is released it is not uncommon for software versions to be over a year (sometimes nearly 2 or more years) 'out of date'. But they don't ignore security issues. Debian package maintainers work tirelessly to backport security patches to the specific versions in the Debian repos. So yes, by doing a simple version check, on face value it would appear that the 2.x version of OTRS (as included in TKL OTRS appliance) has many security bugs - but as is often the case, the face value is in fact incorrect.
Sometimes a new version may have new features or improved functionality and an old version (in the Debian repos) may have a few (non-security) bugs, but the version from the Debian repos will be rock solid stable and as I said above will have all the security patches backported and applied (TKL auto checks for them on first boot and again every night and auto installs them as soon as they become available). So security is a non issue with Debian packages (despite what upstream may report on a simple version check).
As far as other TKL appliances go, it does sometimes get a little tricky. When Debian packages are so out of date that they lack basic required functionality or sometimes the software isn't already packaged by Debian at all. In these cases TKL devs install from upstream. Appliances with upstream software are a little more problematic as they will require manual updating to reduce security risks but many users successfully stick with the 'out of date' versions and apply patches and/or tweaks themselves to mitigate security issues and keep regular (automated) backups using TKLBAM. If any issues arise, they simply restore a recent backup to a clean appliance instance. However this situation doesn't apply to the OTRS appliance (if you check on the indivdual appliance page you can see whether the software is from Debian repos or upstream). If you have any troubles working out where specific software comes from, I am happy to help you uncover how that knowledge can be aquired.
So for future reference could I suggest that it's probably better to be a little less aggressive and avoid spouting until you have all the facts. Otherwise you risk coming across as a bit of a tool. Generally if something doesn't make sense to me, or looks not quite right, I think it is safer to assume that I am missing something and that there is some reason behind it (that I have failed to grasp), rather than assume that those involved (users and developers) are idiots (or whatever)...
So bottom line is, if TKL doesn't work for you, that's fine, don't use it. Remeber the appliances are a gift. If you aren't interested in the gift that's your perogative\. If you have some feedback (even if it's critical) that's fine too, in fact it's encouraged. But please present it respectfully because my perception of the attitude you present above can get people like me (that devote a lot of time and effort to this project) offside instantly. And it's just not neccessary... With kinder more measured words, you could have raised the same point, made the same criticisms and got a somewhat similar answer; all without getting me on the defensive and making me think that perhaps you are a bit of an arrogant uninformed ass...